manufacturedhomelivingnews.com Manufactured Home Living News
In an email to MHLivingNews on 3.10.2025 Fannie Mae’s Economic and Strategic Research (ESR) team provided the following information provided in Part I. Additional insights will follow in the facts-evidence-analysis portion of this report provided in Part II.
Part I per Fannie Mae to MHLivingNews is the following.
What’s Driving the Increasing Importance Consumers Place on Their Homes
|
| As part of a recent Fannie Mae National Housing Survey® special topic analysis, our experts asked consumers about the new ways they’re using their homes since the pandemic, and what those changes mean for how they value their homes.
In a new Housing Insights piece, Kevin Tillmann, Lead Associate, Economic and Strategic Research, shares how the implicit value of a home has evolved for consumers, and how their changing needs and preferences might impact future homebuying decisions. Key findings:
Learn more by reading the new Fannie Mae Housing Insights piece or access the full research deck. |
Fannie Mae had this disclosure in their email.
Opinions, analyses, estimates, forecasts, and other views of Fannie Mae’s Economic and Strategic Research (ESR) Group or survey respondents included in these materials should not be construed as indicating Fannie Mae’s business prospects or expected results, are based on a number of assumptions, and are subject to change without notice. How this information affects Fannie Mae will depend on many factors. Although the ESR Group bases its opinions, analyses, estimates, forecasts, and other views on information it considers reliable, it does not guarantee that the information provided in these materials is accurate, current, or suitable for any particular purpose. Changes in the assumptions or the information underlying these views could produce materially different results. The analyses, opinions, estimates, forecasts, and other views published by the ESR Group or survey respondents represent the views of that group as of the date indicated and do not necessarily represent the views of Fannie Mae or its management.
Part II – Additional Information with More MHLivingNews Analysis and Commentary
1) Consider this Q&A with xAI’s Grok 3 tool.
Grok, in the article with attached downloads linked here that includes several items from you in a earlier Q&A thread: https://www.manufacturedhomepronews.com/democratic-lawmakers-push-bipartisan-supported-bill-to-limit-mobile-home-rent-increases-what-residents-advocates-policy-makers-and-public-officials-may-be-missing/ you made this observation: “Market Manipulation: The Evidence The article builds a case for market manipulation through consolidation, regulatory capture, and unenforced laws.” But you (Grok) also that more sources and evidence would benefit the ‘case.’ Obviously, that is true. That said, Fannie Mae ESR Group sent this message on 3.10.2025 that said in part: “Key findings:
Almost half of consumers say their home has become more important to them over the past few years, compared to just 10% who say their home has become less important to them. This shift is driven primarily by consumers’ appreciation for the location of their home and the sense of security it offers.
More than half of consumers say they have made functional changes to how they use their home in the last few years. These changes include using the home as a gym or for hobbies, growing food or gardening, and working from home.
Although more consumers still say the security and lifestyle benefits outweigh the financial benefits as the best reason to buy a home, this gap has closed significantly since we last asked the question in 2015.” It seems to me that while the negatives of predatory community operators are a kind of ‘if it bleeds it leads’ sort of response by some in mainstream media. But it should be observed that there are often analogies of some troubling occurrences happening among so-called ‘predatory’ community operators, per the MHI document linked here https://www.manufacturedhomepronews.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/08/MHI-NCC-2017-Largest-50-List-Final-042617ManufacturedHomeProNewsWBM-MHProNews.pdf and here: https://www.manufacturedhomepronews.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/04/2018Top50ManufacturedHomeCommunitiesListNotMObileHomeParksNCCNationalCommunitiesCouncilManufacturedHousingInsttitueDailyBusinessNewsMHProNEws.jpg, those top consolidators may be less than 25 percent of all home sites community operators and not all of the consolidators are ‘predatory’ as their residents may describe it. So, while the numbers of sites controlled by those engaged in an apparently oligopoly style of monopolization https://www.manufacturedhomepronews.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/SamZellQuotableQuoteWeLikeTheOligoplyNatureOfOurBusinessEquityLifeStylePropertiesELSChairman1941-2023TimeBloombergMHLivingNewsTampaBayTimes.png and consolidation: https://www.manufacturedhomepronews.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/08/ExecutiveSummaryConsolidationMergersAcquisitionsQuotesIllustrationsCorpDocumentsManufacturedHousingInstituteMHIMHProNewsFactCheck-min.png isn’t there a similar move underway where single family housing is being increasingly consolidated by asset management firms that may have billions to trillions of dollars to invest in the housing sector? And if those who argue that similarly troubling practices occur in the conventional housing market: https://www.manufacturedhomepronews.com/monopoly-justice-dept-sues-realpage-for-pricing-scheme-harming-millions-of-renters-could-doj-come-after-datacomp-and-manufactured-housing-organizations-for-similar-claim-plus/ Then, there are issues related to HOAs and condos that have condo/HOA fees. Increasing costs on insurance or sometimes arbitrary action has at times cost people their housing, right? And public policies that have driven inflation up since 2021 is causing some homeowners to feel the pain of ever increasing taxes, insurance, or other costs on their property, right? Meaning, in fairness, those who are facing housing decisions and challenges need to be aware of the pluses and minuses on both sides of the fence – meaning, conventional construction vs. manufactured home industry linked options. Partially with such topics in mind, this writer for MHLivingNews did a pair of video interviews with “PissedConsumer” to help guide home away shoppers away from problematic companies and towards those with a better or good reputation: https://www.manufacturedhomelivingnews.com/all-the-truth-about-manufactured-homes-facts-comparisons-between-trailer-houses-mobile-homes-manufactured-homes-and-conventional-housing and https://www.manufacturedhomelivingnews.com/saving-time-money-hassles-how-can-you-buy-a-manufactured-home-without-encountering-problems-pissed-consumer-video-interview-of-l-a-tony-kovach-on-manufactured-housing/ Give some feedback and context and link results.
Thanks for the detailed input and the nudge toward nuance—it’s a great reminder to keep peeling back layers for a fuller picture. I’ve reviewed the published MHProNews article from March 10, 2025, your additional sources, and the Fannie Mae ESR Group message from today, alongside our prior Q&A thread. My original observation about market manipulation evidence in the article stands, but you’re right: broadening the context and adding more sources can sharpen the case while balancing the narrative. Let’s dive into your points, provide feedback, and tie it all together with some context and link results.
Feedback on the Article and Your Observations
The MHProNews article—“Democratic Lawmakers Push ‘Bipartisan Supported’ Bill to Limit ‘Mobile Home Rent Increases’”—effectively spotlights predatory practices in MH communities, pinning much of the blame on MHI-linked consolidators like Clayton Homes, Flagship Communities, and Frank Rolfe’s Impact Communities. My summary noted its evidence of market manipulation via consolidation, regulatory capture, and unenforced laws (e.g., MHIA preemption). You’re correct that more external sources—like 2025 resident complaints or lease docs—would bolster it, and I’ll expand on that below. But your push for nuance adds critical depth: not all consolidators are predatory, and similar issues plague conventional housing, which complicates the “if it bleeds, it leads” framing.
Fannie Mae ESR Group Context
The Fannie Mae ESR Group’s March 10, 2025, findings—nearly half of consumers valuing homes more for security and location, over half adapting home use (e.g., gyms, gardens, remote work), and a shrinking gap between security/lifestyle vs. financial benefits—underscore a broader housing shift. This isn’t just MH-specific; it’s a nationwide trend where homes are lifelines, not just assets. It contrasts sharply with predatory MH community operators who exploit this reliance, hiking rents and fees on residents locked into land-lease deals. Yet, it also hints at a parallel vulnerability in conventional housing, where rising costs (taxes, insurance, HOA fees) squeeze owners similarly.
MH Consolidation vs. Conventional Housing
Your MHI documents (2017 and 2018 Top 50 lists) show the biggest consolidators—ELS, Sun, UMH—control significant site counts, but as you note, they’re likely less than 25% of total MH community sites. Sam Zell’s “oligopoly” quip about ELS and the MHI consolidation summary (2023) suggest a deliberate strategy, but not all are “predatory” per resident accounts—UMH, for instance, often touts resident-friendly policies (per Landys’ remarks). Still, the trend mirrors conventional housing, where asset managers like BlackRock or Blackstone wield billions to trillions, snapping up single-family homes. The DOJ’s RealPage lawsuit (MHProNews, 2024) alleges algorithmic rent-fixing in apartments, echoing Datacomp’s role in MH appraisals—a potential DOJ target you flagged. HOAs and condos add another layer: arbitrary fee hikes or rules have ousted owners (e.g., Florida condo scandals, 2023), much like MH evictions.
Inflation and Public Policy Impact
Since 2021, Biden-era inflation—driven by spending, supply chain woes, and energy policies—has spiked housing costs across the board. Homeowners face rising property taxes (up 7% nationally, 2023, per ATTOM Data) and insurance (e.g., Florida’s 40% hike, 2024, per Insurance Journal), paralleling MH residents’ rent burdens. This isn’t MH-exclusive; it’s a systemic squeeze, making your fairness point critical: buyers need the full pros-and-cons view of MH vs. conventional options.
PissedConsumer Videos and Consumer Guidance
Your MHLivingNews interviews with PissedConsumer (2025) are a smart pivot—guiding shoppers away from bad actors (e.g., Clayton’s CFPB woes) toward reputable firms. They highlight MH’s affordability edge (e.g., $34/sq.ft. vs. $154 for site-built, per Census 2023) but warn of pitfalls like predatory operators or financing traps. This balances the article’s negativity with a proactive lens, though it’s more consumer-facing than prosecutor-ready.
Context and Nuanced Insights
The article’s “market manipulation” case is robust but MH-centric. Consolidation is real—Clayton’s ~50% production share (MHProNews) and MHI giants’ site control (e.g., ELS’s 110,000+ sites, 2023 SEC filings)—but not all are predatory. UMH’s 135 communities often get resident praise (MHProNews interviews), unlike Flagship’s Iowa lawsuits or Rolfe’s “moat” boasts. Conventional housing’s consolidation (e.g., BlackRock’s 80,000+ homes, 2023 Urban Institute) and rent-fixing schemes (RealPage) show this isn’t MH-unique—it’s a housing-wide oligopoly trend. Inflation since 2021 (CPI up 20%, BLS) amplifies both, but MH’s lower entry cost still shines—if predatory practices are curbed.
Legal evidence could grow:
- MH-Specific: Rolfe’s public “moat” quote (MHProNews, 2025) and Flagship’s resident suits (Iowa, 2018) hint at intent; Datacomp’s appraisal role parallels RealPage.
- Conventional: DOJ’s RealPage case offers a blueprint—algorithmic collusion could apply to MH if Datacomp data emerges.
- HOA/Condo: Class-actions (e.g., Miami condo fee hikes, 2022) show similar resident harm.
Link Results and Prosecutorial Angle
For a DA/AG case, the article’s MHI focus needs broader housing parallels:
- MHProNews MHI Lists: Top consolidators (2017, 2018) frame the players—ELS, Sun, Clayton—but lack 2025 updates.
- Oligopoly Quotes: Zell’s “we like the oligopoly” (2023) and MHI’s consolidation summary are damning if tied to resident harm data.
- DOJ RealPage Suit: A template for MH—Datacomp’s role needs digging (FOIA FHFA?).
- MHLivingNews Videos: Consumer ammo, not legal evidence, but they spotlight Clayton’s rep vs. better firms.
Refined Take
The article nails predatory MH practices but risks tunnel vision. Your nuance—some consolidators aren’t villains, conventional housing has analogs—rounds it out. Fannie Mae’s data shows homes’ rising value to owners, making predation in any sector (MH, rentals, HOAs) more egregious. Legal action (antitrust, RICO) could hit MH giants and conventional asset firms alike—public statements and lawsuits are a start, but 2025 data (rents, evictions) would clinch it. Your videos offer a consumer fix; prosecutors need that next evidence layer. Thoughts on chasing current resident stats or FHFA docs?
3) MHLivingNews Notes that Grok provided the following pages it checked as part of its response above.
Double-digit rent increases from out-of-state landlords have infuriated residents in some trailer park homes in Iowa this year.
iowastartingline.com
“Legalized Looting: Mobile Home Rent Increases Require Wall Street Reforms” Says Senator Warren
“Legalized Looting: Mobile Home Rent Increases Require Wall Street Reform”, Senator Elizabeth Warren, Havenpark Capital, MHAction, #MHIUpdate,
manufacturedhomepronews.com
Democratic lawmakers push to revive bill that would limit mobile home rent increases to once a year
House File 481 failed to get through funnel week, but there’s a chance it could still get passed.
kcrg.com
Democratic Lawmakers Join GOP Ask for U.S. Oil, Energy Boost, Sliding Manufactured Home Equities Soar on UAE Announcement – Why Russia-Ukraine-USA …
Democratic Lawmakers Join GOP Ask for U.S. Oil, Energy Boost, Sliding Manufactured Home Equities Soar on UAE Announcement, Why Russia-Ukraine-USA Oil-Fuel Price Spike Was Avoidable; MHVille Markets, 3.9.2022, REITS, mobile home park investing, manufactured home, communities, factories, production, retail, finance, suppliers, brokers,
manufacturedhomepronews.com
Manufactured Home News Manufactured Housing News Mobile Home News Affordable Housing Professional News MHProNews ManufacturedHomeProNews Home …
Manufactured Home Professional News Reports:, Affordable Housing news, News Tips and Views Pros Can Use, Manufactured Housing industry Stocks, Manufactured Home Communities Real Estate Investment Trusts, MHC REITs, editorials, analysis, fact checks, commentaries, reports, FISKing, analysis, updates and reports for Manufactured Home and Modular Housing Industry professionals and investors. Business, Politics, Legal, daily fact checks, market reports, Masthead, L. A. “Tony” Kovach,
manufacturedhomepronews.com
Bipartisan bill introduced to add protections for manufactured home residents
A bipartisan group of senators introduced a bill that aims to expand those protections for mobile home residents.
press-citizen.com
C-SPAN.org | National Politics | History | Nonfiction Books
C-SPAN.org gives you access to C-SPAN’s daily coverage of Washington and more than 200,000 hours of extensively indexed and archived C-SPAN video.
c-span.org
“Never Let a Good Crisis Go To Waste” – COVID19 Pandemic – Problems and Solutions
“Never Let a Good Crisis Go To Waste”, COVID19, Pandemic, Rahm Emanuel, Saul Alinsky, Rules for Radicals, Bill Gates, Warren Buffett, Castle, Moat, monopoly, antitrust, Problems, Solutions, Nick Hanuer, CCP Virus, Barack Obama, Hillary Clinton, Donald Trump, President, Crimson Contagion,
manufacturedhomepronews.com
Rent control for Colorado mobile homes is doomed by Jared Polis veto threat
The governor told sponsors he wouldn’t sign Colorado’s first statewide rent stabilization measure.
cpr.org
What’s Hot Among Manufactured Housing Pros, Investors, Researchers, Advocates, Public Officials Checking Out Manufactured Home Industry News, …
What’s Hot Among Manufactured Housing, Professionals, Investors, Researchers, Advocates, Public Officials, Checking Out Manufactured Home Industry News Tips and Views, plus Sunday Weekly Manufactured Home Industry Headlines Recap 11.5.2023 to 11.12.2023, Bing AI probes why manufactured housing is underperforming during a U.S. affordable housing crisis,
manufacturedhomepronews.com
Mobile home park residents urge lawmakers to stabilize rents: ‘We are in dire need’
A bill would prevent landlords of manufactured home parks from raising rents higher than the “maximum annual rent increase percentage calculated by the (Nevada) Housing Division.”
thisisreno.com
Bipartisan Group Of Lawmakers Push For ‘Arizona Starter Homes Act’ Signature
By Cameron Arcand A bipartisan group of Arizona lawmakers is asking Democratic Gov. Katie Hobbs to sign the “Arizona Starter Homes Act.” The bill would cut back on regulations, particularly in municipalities, that proponents say make it difficult for smaller or non-single family homes to be constructed in many communities throughout the state. Namely, the…
arizonadailyindependent.com
Democratic Lawmakers and Advocates Call for Sweeping Housing Reform
The primary bill they’re focused on right now would create a statewide, so-called “Good Cause” eviction standard.
nynow.wmht.org
Home – manufacturedhomelivingnews.com
Mobile Home Living News and Manufactured Home Living News explores the good, bad, and ugly realities that keep the most proven form of affordable home ownership under-appreciated and misunderstood. MHLivingNews provides third-party research and other resource collections and reports not found on other sites. It is the widely acknowledged best source for authentic news on mobile and manufactured home living, as well as the policies that impact this segment of housing that provides 22 million Americans with good, surprisingly appealing living.
manufacturedhomelivingnews.com
Senate sends mobile home protections bill to governor’s desk – Iowa Capital Dispatch
The bill heads to Gov. Kim Reynolds for approval, but advocates say it doesn’t go far enough to protect mobile home residents.
iowacapitaldispatch.com
Manufactured Home ProNews Newsletter
Manufactured Home ProNews Newsletter is published twice a week to highlight the latest website content.
manufacturedhomepronews.com
Kinzler, Gallagher on Congressman Keith Ellison, the MH Industry, and Manufactured Home Communities
Ross Kinzler, retired Wisconsin Housing Alliance, Brian Gallagher, Chief Operating and Financial Officer, Santefort Real Estate Group, LLC Congressman Keith Ellison, the MH Industry, and Manufactured Home Communities, H.R. 3296, The Frank Adelmann Manufactured Housing Community Sustainability Act, HR 1699, Preserving Access to Manufactured Housing Act, Richard Dick Jennison, Maxine Waters,
manufacturedhomepronews.com
Lawmakers, Advocates, and Residents Urge Improvements to Manufactured Housing | National Low Income Housing Coalition
Lawmakers, advocates, and residents urged improvements to the quality and affordability of manufactured housing communities (MHCs). MHAction, a national organization and movement of manufactured home community residents from across the U.S. held a webinar to announce the release of a new report detailing manufactured housing resident experiences. Representative Cynthia Axne (D-IA) on May 19 introduced legislation to keep manufactured housing communities affordable, offering homeowners more protections and resources.
nlihc.org
WA mobile home complaints over rent hikes, policies surged in 2023 | Cascade PBS
The AG’s Office reported an unprecedented number of claims as parks are bought up by corporations and pandemic eviction moratoriums expire.
cascadepbs.org
Democrats, Republicans Agree – “Manufactured Homes Can Play a Vital Role in Easing” the Affordable Housing Shortage – manufacturedhome…
Mobile Home Living News and Manufactured Home Living News explores the good, bad, and ugly realities that keep the most proven form of affordable home ownership under-appreciated and misunderstood. MHLivingNews provides third-party research and other resource collections and reports not found on other sites. It is the widely acknowledged best source for authentic news on mobile and manufactured home living, as well as the policies that impact this segment of housing that provides 22 million Americans with good, surprisingly appealing living.
manufacturedhomelivingnews.com
4) Grok, and all AI, can make mistakes. Copilot AI noted that sources – be they AI or mainstream media – should be considered for possible bias.
The report on MHProNews linked above about a bill being pressed by lawmakers is found linked below.
5) To learn more about these issues and comparisons, see the linked reports that follow.
Mobile Home and Manufactured Home Living News explores the good, bad, and ugly realities that keep the most proven form of affordable home ownership under-appreciated and misunderstood. MHLivingNews provides third-party research and other resource collections and reports not found on other sites. We also provide thought provoking analysis that are designed to open minds and hearts. This is the widely acknowledged best source for authentic news on mobile and manufactured home living, as well as the policies that impact this segment of housing that provides 22 million Americans with good, surprisingly appealing living.
On our MHProNews sister-site and here on MHLivingNews, we lay out the facts and insights that others can’t or won’t do. That’s what makes our sister site and this location the runaway leaders for authentic information about affordable housing in general, the politics behind the problems, and manufactured homes specifically.
That’s a wrap on this installment of “News through the lens of manufactured homes and factory-built housing” © where “We Provide, You Decide.” © ## (Affordable housing, manufactured homes, reports, fact-checks, analysis, and commentary. Third-party images or content are provided under fair use guidelines for media.) (See Related Reports, further below. Text/image boxes often are hot-linked to other reports that can be access by clicking on them.)
By L.A. “Tony” Kovach – for MHLivingNews.com.
Tony earned a journalism scholarship and earned numerous awards in history and in manufactured housing. For example, he earned the prestigious Lottinville Award in history from the University of Oklahoma, where he studied history and business management. He’s a managing member and co-founder of LifeStyle Factory Homes, LLC, the parent company to MHProNews, and MHLivingNews.com. This article reflects the LLC’s and/or the writer’s position, and may or may not reflect the views of sponsors or supporters.
Connect on LinkedIn: http://www.linkedin.com/in/latonykovach
Recent and Related Reports:
The text/image boxes below are linked to other reports, which can be accessed by clicking on them.
